2011 January 18 Tuesday
Electronic Patient Records Offer Little Benefit?

A meta-analysis finds little evidence for the improved outcomes from using electronic medical records and other information systems in medicine.

Despite the wide endorsement of and support for eHealth technologies, such as electronic patient records and e-prescribing, the scientific basis of its benefits—which are repeatedly made and often uncritically accepted—remains to be firmly established.

Furthermore, even for the eHealth technologies that have proven to be successful, there is little evidence to show that such tools would continue to be successful beyond the contexts in which they were originally developed. These are the key findings of a study by Aziz Sheikh (University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, Scotland) and colleagues, and published in this week's PLoS Medicine.

In the study, the authors systematically reviewed the published systematic review literature on eHealth technologies and evaluated the impact of these technologies on the quality and safety of health care delivery. The 53 reviews (out of 108), that the authors selected according to their criteria and critically reviewed, provided the main evidence base for assessing the impact of eHealth technologies in three categories: 1) storing, managing, and transmission of data, such as electronic patient records; 2) clinical decision support, such as e-prescribing; and 3) facilitating care from a distance, such as telehealthcare devices.

The authors found that the evidence base in support of eHealth technologies was weak and inconsistent and, importantly, that there is insubstantial evidence to support the cost-effectiveness of these technologies. They also found some evidence that introducing these new technologies may sometimes generate new risks, such as prescribing practitioners becoming over-reliant on clinical decision support for e-prescribing or overestimate its functionality, resulting in decreased practitioner performance.

Quite a few new technologies offer only small initial benefits and substantial costs. But later their benefits soar and their costs drop. I expect the same will happen with electronic medical records. Computer software that does diagnosis holds considerable promise because as it becomes more capable it should produce more accurate diagnoses on average as compared to humans.

One big long term benefit from electronic medical records will come from the ability to feed test results in to diagnostics expert systems. The more health and medical tests information that is captured electronically the more of it that can be fed into diagnostics applications.

By Randall Parker    2011 January 18 11:18 PM   Entry Permalink | Comments (6)
Site Traffic Info